Virginia’s Shoes

I just learned about cross-posting, and in the spirit of adventure, I’m trying it. Below is a post that Virginia has just put up on her blog Beauty Schooled. Virginia is the one who’s been posting about her beauty routine, and she’s fabulous, as you’ll soon see, if you haven’t already been to her blog. One of my posts will be appearing simultaneously on both of our blogs soon. After I write it. Which will be really soon. My fiancé just bought me a box of donuts, so I have plenty of material to work with.

Just a quick note before I hand it over to Virginia: We saw the movie Just Wright over the weekend (you know, we were on our way to see a thoughtful, poignant, and edgy independent film based on a Pulitzer prize winning set of short stories called “Contemplations of the Cracked Doorstop,” when a dashing man with steely eyes in a tux helped a stunning woman in a red silk evening gown into our stopped cab, forcing us out at gunpoint. He addressed her as “your majesty,” and then said in a voice as cool as January, “Driver. Go. As if your life depends on it.” As the cab screeched away from the curb, a horde of men dressed in black with guns burst around the corner. We threw ourselves onto the pavement and when we stood up, they were gone. And we were directly across the street from an AMC. We really didn’t have the strength to go any farther). Anyway, Just Wright, despite it’s awful title, was adorable! It made me think a lot about how rare it is for a story to have a heavyset female protagonist, let alone one who is cast in a romantic role. Queen Latifah was totally gorgeous, and her romance feels like a victory for womankind. Which is sort of sad, since it should be completely normal for a big woman to be with a thin guy. And yet it isn’t. At all. Anyway, sorry, my “quick note” got kind of long. The point is: Hooray for media depictions of full-bodied women being strong and sexy and getting the guy. It made me happy.

And now………

MONDAY’S BEAUTY SCHOOLED POST:

The Shoe Astronauts lied to you.

Just catching up on my Google Reader (is anyone else always chronically, despairingly behind on their blog reading?) and this caught my eye over on Jezebel:

Christian Louboutin in the Met Ball: “There were a lot of women wearing my shoes. And some of them came up to me and told me they were uncomfortable!”
I kind of love this. Not Christian — did you really not already know your shoes are so damn pinchy? But the whole idea of women at the Met Ball being like, “dude, WTF already!”

Confession time: I absolutely love shoes.

I have a ridiculously large collection that I keep arranged by color on all these shelves in my closet. When I left my last office job, they had to messenger home the three boxes of shoes that lived under my desk. I’m the type of person that people are always giving shoe greeting cards and shoe calendars. (Plus cat-themed things, which is a whole other story. Dear world, I’m full up on both fronts now.)

And so, I’m at a point where I’m feeling embarrassed about how much I love them, because Carrie Bradshaw et al have put shoes firmly on a Stuff Women Like List that I find sometimes oppressive. I won’t attempt a comprehensive catalog here but other highlights include chocolate, cats and purses. Which are also things I happen to like, dammit.

What I don’t like is the way this List is used to be patronizing to women or enable women to patronize themselves —that Bridget Jones Syndrome where if you like these things you can’t possibly have more serious thoughts on Real Issues because you’re too busy counting calories and moaning over why he hasn’t called yet. You can like shoes and still be a good feminist/driver/person who recycles. I shouldn’t have to explain that again.

I also don’t like how the List makes women feel bad about themselves if they happen to have girl parts and yet mysteriously not love these things. It worries me when I talk to women who hate shoes, because I hear a lot of fear mixed with defensiveness — that they could never walk in heels that high, that they’ll get blisters and break an ankle, that they’ve failed on some essential female front by not being the type of woman who loves shoes.

That’s hogwash. And it’s also the fault of women like me — a group I’ll call the Shoe Astronauts. We’re probably the reason for that List in the first place. We like to walk around in ridiculously high shoes and say nonchalant things like, “they’re actually really comfortable!”

Translation: They’re slowly crushing my fifth metatarsal into oblivion, but I have the Right Stuff, so I can stand it. You there, in your Dansko clogs, are made from an inferior form of estrogen. And you don’t know where to shop.

I once insisted a new pair of strappy sandals were so comfortable, I could walk in them for miles. And I did. Right up until my boyfriend looked down and informed me that I was leaving a trail of blood behind us on the sidewalk.

“But they’re so comfortable,” I said.

I’m working on it. I don’t want to be the reason that another woman feels bad about herself (or her feet). I’m recognizing that this too is a beauty standard that I have conformed to relentlessly and unquestioningly for years. My style has also evolved (thanks working from home!) so I run around in a pair of laceless Converse sneakers most of the time.*

But I still love shoes, in a heart-stopping, heady, where-did-you-get-those-red-peep-toe-slingbacks way. And I still wear beautiful shoes when I go somewhere Important, and I’ll be damned if I’m ever going to be the bridesmaid who takes her shoes off as soon as she hits the reception and dances barefoot all night. Instead I bring cute flats to change into so I don’t have to suffer for more than two hours. And I no longer pretend shoes are comfortable when they aren’t.

I’ll just admit it: Sometimes, I love things that aren’t so good for me.

*Sorry Dankso. I still have my pride.

9 Comments »

Kate on May 17th 2010 in beauty, guest post

9 Responses to “Virginia’s Shoes”

  1. The Shoe Astronauts lied to you. « Beauty Schooled responded on 17 May 2010 at 1:09 pm #

    [...] lied to you. Jump to Comments Goodness! I am so excited because today’s post will be cross-posted over at Eat the Damn Cake, one of my new favorite body image blogs. Kate is honest, hilarious, and [...]

  2. Rob (R.M. Levitt) responded on 17 May 2010 at 5:56 pm #

    As a guy, I have to offer my $0.02 by saying high heels are a huge turn-off to me. Especially stilettos. To me they look tawdry and, along with perhaps a cigarette in the mouth and too much makeup, display a kind of jaded sophistication that I find very unappealing. That’s only my opinion, and I’m sure many men would disagree, but I myself walk right past women like that without looking twice. It’s just not a look that makes me want to get to know her better.

    As you probably know, high heels were designed to make women walk with small, “delicate” steps, at the expense of hurting their backs and legs, mangling their toes, and giving them hideous callouses and bunions. In that regard, I don’t see how they’re much different than a “lite” version of the foot-binding historically practiced by the Chinese. I happen to think girls’ feet can be very attractive, but only if they haven’t been destroyed in that way.

    Again, just offering one particular male perspective that might help some of you see things “from the other side” so to speak.

  3. Wei-Wei responded on 17 May 2010 at 7:42 pm #

    This post is awesome! I love shoes, too, but they aren’t high on my list of loves. We women are entitled so some collective favourites, no? It doesn’t make us any less… womanly? Self-worthy? Esteemed? Hey, we all know that all guys like some things, too. Even though that may be a generalisation, it’s probably safe to say that all, or most, women like “girly” things to some degree. Same goes for men.

    I actually usually prize comfortable shoes over uncomfortable ones. That said, the uncomfortable ones are usually someone else’s and don’t fit well, so if I find an “uncomfortable,” (notice the quotation marks) fitting shoes (is that an oxymoron?) that happen to just be so gorgeous, then I’ll be walking miles in them, no matter what! :D Okay, maybe that’s an exaggeration and I’d probably be hobbling and have already changed shoes with someone else by, say, the first mile, but still. Shoes. Are awesome. (Did you know that all shoes are designed with some sort of sexual image in mind, consciously or unconsciously? That’s why they’re so sexy, no?)

  4. San D responded on 18 May 2010 at 5:54 am #

    I love shoes too. Quel surprise! I have taken my love to a comfort level called: KEENS. My feet have thanked me many times over. And as for the male response, I have long suspected that men think a lot of what we are programmed to do is just plain silliness, from makeup to squishing our feet into heels. My gut is that women dress for women, and that men would prefer their mates au naturale. I’m just sayin…..

  5. Kate responded on 18 May 2010 at 12:40 pm #

    My only pair of comfortable high heels broke yesterday. It was pretty upsetting. I love clothes, and I love shoes, and I have been known to wear uncomfortable versions of both because I thought I looked hot. And honestly, I don’t have a huge problem with that.

    I would have a problem with destroying my feet and living in constant pain in order to worship at the patent leather pointed toe of the god of high fashion, but dressing up once in a while makes me feel good, and I value feeling good (and sexy) a lot.

    I see no reason why I can’t be totally schlumpy some days, and totally put together others. And I find no reason why I can’t use any of the tools available to me to facilitate either state!

    (Also, I have definitely felt hot while being schlumpy! No need for some huge dichotomy! Sexiness is everywhere!)

  6. Wck responded on 18 May 2010 at 1:53 pm #

    Ok, that thing about the guy with the gun and the princess in the beginning was the funniest thing ever. You’re ridiculous. I kinda love you.

  7. Sarah responded on 19 May 2010 at 6:56 pm #

    I love shoes too. And I have to say, I’m guilty of saying nonchalantly, when someone has remarked on the height of my heel: “Oh, they’re completely comfortable too.” It’s really kind of IS a way of being a jerk and inferring that there must be something wrong with THEM for wearing a comfortable shoe to a part. The shame. And horror.

    I’ve never had a pair of Louboutins, and have always secretly believed them to be incredibly comfortable due to fine craftmanship and extreme price. Are you trying to tell me this isn’t true?! Four inch heels aren’t more comfortable than three??

  8. Lena responded on 20 May 2010 at 10:42 am #

    Good cross post!! Thanks for this, Kate and Virginia!

  9. The Shoe Astronauts Lied To You. responded on 25 Jan 2012 at 6:12 pm #

    [...] I am so excited because today’s post will be cross-posted over at Eat the Damn Cake, one of my new favorite body image blogs. Kate is honest, hilarious, and [...]

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply